ss-tools/specs/038-dashboard-scenario-model/validation.md

#region DashboardScenarioModel.ValidationReport [C:3] [TYPE ADR] [SEMANTICS validation,gate,scenario] @defgroup Validation Pre-implementation validation gate for the Dashboard Scenario Model.

Status: PASS

Date: 2026-07-31 Feature: 038 Dashboard Scenario Model Branch: 038-dashboard-scenario-model (spec reworked on 037 branch; implementation branch to be created)

Validated Inputs

Artifact	Size (bytes)	Modified (UTC)	SHA-256
spec.md	reworked	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
plan.md	reworked	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
tasks.md	reworked (56 tasks)	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
traceability.md	reworked	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
ux_reference.md	reworked	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
contracts/modules.md	belief-runtime annotations added	2026-07-31	reworked-per-new-flow
contracts/openapi.yaml	standardized (7 ops)	2026-07-31	validated: 3.1, 7 unique operationIds, security on mutating ops
contracts/openapi-traceability.md	new	2026-07-31	7 operations traced
prototype/index.html	new (18 states)	2026-07-31	state coverage 100%
prototype/manifest.md	new	2026-07-31	24 state classes covered
contracts/ux/	edge matrix + alternatives added	2026-07-31	24 classes evaluated

NOTE: Actual SHA-256 digests to be recorded by the implementer when running /speckit.validate on the dedicated 038-dashboard-scenario-model branch. This report documents the rework-time validation.

Blocking Findings

✅ No blocking findings. Proceed to /speckit.implement (after branch creation).

Warning Findings

ID	Check	Severity	Location	Finding
W01	Branch alignment	WARNING	git branch	Spec lives on 037-superset-baseline-engine; implementation branch 038-dashboard-scenario-model must be created before implementation
W02	SHA-256 provenance	WARNING	validation.md	Real digests to be recorded on the 038 branch run
W03	Frontend verification	WARNING	tasks.md	No frontend tasks (DTO-only); 039 owns rendering — confirm 039 has its own UI tasks

Check Results

Phase 1: Unresolved Markers

• TODO/TKTK/???: 0
• Status: ✅ PASS

Phase 2: Artifact Completeness

Artifact	Expected	Present	Status
spec.md	required	✅	PASS
plan.md	required	✅	PASS
tasks.md	required	✅	PASS
traceability.md	required	✅	PASS
ux_reference.md	required	✅	PASS
contracts/modules.md	required	✅	PASS
contracts/openapi.yaml	API surface	✅	PASS
contracts/openapi-traceability.md	API surface	✅	PASS
prototype/index.html	UI surface	✅	PASS
prototype/manifest.md	UI surface	✅	PASS
contracts/ux/scenario-graph-ux.md	UI surface	✅	PASS
contracts/ux/alternatives.md	UI surface	✅	PASS
data-model.md	required	✅	PASS
research.md	required	✅	PASS
checklist-catalog.md	required	✅	PASS
fixtures/	plan references	✅ (task T003/T004)	PASS

Phase 3: Schema & Contract Validation

• YAML parse: ✅ (openapi.yaml, 3.1)
• operationId uniqueness: ✅ (7 unique)
• Contract audit: ✅ region pairs balanced across all 038 artifacts
• ATTN rules: ✅ ScenarioGraph.* hierarchical IDs; shared [SEMANTICS scenario,...]

Phase 4: Reference & ADR Integrity

• ADR continuity: ✅ ADR-0001/0002/0005 acknowledged in plan; 037 no-SQL invariant propagated to validator contract
• Cross-reference integrity: ✅ all task refs in traceability exist (56 tasks); all operationIds traced

Phase 5: Decision-Memory Continuity

• Three-layer chain: ✅ 8 guardrails traced ADR → plan → contracts → tasks (see plan.md Decision Memory table)
• Dangling rationale: 0
• Contradictory resurrection: 0
• Missing guardrail: 0 (all C4/C5 contracts now carry @RATIONALE/@REJECTED; belief-runtime @SIDE_EFFECT added to Capture/VLM/Disposition/Resolver/Serializer)

Phase 6: Task Dependency & Path

• Task count: 56
• Invalid paths: 0
• Circular dependencies: 0
• Phases 1→2→3→4→5→6→7→8→9 ordered; US1→US2 dependency explicit

Phase 7: UX State Coverage

• State matrix coverage: 24/24 state classes evaluated (0 skipped without rationale)
• Prototype coverage: 24/24 represented (18 dedicated sections + grouped/aria-live coverage)
• UX test coverage: ✅ every @UX_TEST in scenario-graph-ux.md mapped to prototype states

Phase 8: Axiom Health

• Index status: to be verified on 038 branch (axiom_search({operation="status"}))
• Orphans: to be verified on 038 branch
• Unresolved relations: 0 in 038 contract artifacts (all @RELATION targets defined or 036/037 cross-spec)

Gate Decision

Verdict: ✅ PASS — /speckit.implement may proceed after creating the 038-dashboard-scenario-model branch and re-recording SHA-256 provenance.

Resolution Instructions

• W01: Create branch 038-dashboard-scenario-model from current HEAD (specs/038 already on disk).
• W02: Re-run /speckit.validate on the 038 branch to record real digests.
• W03: Confirm 039 owns UI rendering tasks; 038 remains DTO-only.

#endregion DashboardScenarioModel.ValidationReport