ss-tools/specs/028-llm-datasource-supeset/plan.md

# Implementation Plan: LLM Table Translation Service

**Branch**: `028-llm-datasource-supeset` | **Date**: 2026-05-08 | **Spec**: [spec.md](./spec.md)
**Input**: Feature specification from `/specs/028-llm-datasource-supeset/spec.md` (updated 2026-05-14 with multi-language & correction optimization)

## Summary

Implement an LLM-powered table translation service as a new backend plugin (`TranslationPlugin`) with companion API routes, ORM models, Pydantic schemas, and Svelte frontend components. The service reads rows from a Superset datasource (translation column + context columns), auto-detects source language per row via LLM, sends batches to a configured LLM provider for ALL target languages simultaneously (multi-target in single structured JSON response), with optional per-batch filtered multilingual terminology dictionary context (language-pair-aware). Generates safe PostgreSQL INSERT/UPSERT SQL, submits to Superset via `/api/v1/sqllab/execute/` with status polling. Supporting capabilities: multilingual terminology dictionaries (source_language + target_language per entry), configurable preview (1-100 rows), inline correction from any run result with dictionary submission, bulk find-and-replace, scheduled execution via APScheduler (new-key-only with baseline_expired fallback), structured event logging with per-language MetricSnapshot persistence, RBAC-gated access control, and 90-day retention with metric continuity.

**Total planned modules**: 31 contracts across backend (Python/FastAPI) and frontend (Svelte 5/SvelteKit).  
**Complexity distribution**: 2× C5 (orchestrator, event-log), 9× C4 (preview, execute, dictionary, scheduler, SQL-gen, routes, correction), 13× C3 (models, schemas, components, services), 7× C2 (helpers, new models).

## Technical Context

**Language/Version**: Python 3.13+ (backend), JavaScript/TypeScript (frontend Svelte 5)  
**Primary Dependencies**: FastAPI 0.115+, SQLAlchemy 2.0+, APScheduler 3.x, Pydantic v2 (backend); SvelteKit 2.x, Svelte 5.43+, Vite 7.x, Tailwind CSS 3.x (frontend)  
**Storage**: PostgreSQL 16 (shared with existing ss-tools schema)  
**Testing**: pytest 8.x + pytest-asyncio (backend); vitest 4.x + @testing-library/svelte 5.x (frontend)  
**Target Platform**: Linux server (Docker Compose: backend + frontend + PostgreSQL)  
**Project Type**: web application — FastAPI REST + WebSocket backend, SvelteKit SPA frontend  
**Performance Goals**: Preview of 10 rows within 30s (LLM-dependent); INSERT generation <5s for 1000 rows; schedule trigger precision ±60s; event recording <10s after occurrence  
**Constraints**: RBAC enforcement via access-control matrix; dictionary per-batch filtering (case-insensitive, word-boundary-aware); 90-day detailed data retention with MetricSnapshot persistence; plugin lifecycle compatible with `PluginBase`; dialect-aware SQL generation (PostgreSQL/Greenplum, ClickHouse supported for MVP); snapshot isolation for in-progress runs; structured JSON LLM output required  
**Scale/Scope**: Tens of thousands of rows per run; dictionaries of any size; 50 concurrent users; 5–10 active translation jobs per deployment

## Constitution Check

*GATE: Must pass before Phase 0 research. Re-check after Phase 1 design.*

| Principle | Status | Evidence |
|-----------|--------|----------|
| **I. Plugin Architecture** | ✅ PASS | Feature implemented as a new plugin inheriting from `PluginBase` (`backend/src/plugins/translate/`), consistent with existing `llm_analysis`, `git`, `storage` plugin pattern. |
| **II. API-First Design** | ✅ PASS | All operations exposed via REST endpoints under `/api/translate/` (jobs, dictionaries, runs, schedules, history) and WebSocket for run progress. Follows existing FastAPI route conventions. |
| **III. Test-First** | ✅ PASS | Acceptance criteria per user story defined in spec; test strategy in research.md covers unit (pytest), integration (API + DB), and component (vitest + Svelte Testing Library) layers. |
| **IV. RBAC & Security** | ✅ PASS | Granular permissions (`translate.job.*`, `translate.dictionary.*`, `translate.schedule.manage`, `translate.history.view`) via existing RBAC model. API keys encrypted via `EncryptionManager`. PII masking for LLM-facing context per existing patterns. |
| **V. Observability & Retention** | ✅ PASS | Structured Translation Events (FR-046), per-job metrics (FR-047), notification integration (FR-048), 90-day retention with pruning (FR-049). C4+ flows instrumented with `belief_scope`/`reason`/`reflect`/`explore` markers. |
| **Semantic Protocol Compliance** | ✅ PASS | All planned modules assigned `@COMPLEXITY` 1–5 with appropriate tag density per GRACE complexity scale (C1: anchor only, C2: +BRIEF, C3: +RELATION, C4: +PRE/POST/SIDE_EFFECT, C5: +DATA_CONTRACT/INVARIANT/RATIONALE/REJECTED). `@RATIONALE`/`@REJECTED` reserved for C5 contracts only. Canonical `@RELATION PREDICATE -> TARGET_ID` syntax. Anchor format: `#region`/`#endregion` for Python, `<!-- #region -->`/`<!-- #endregion -->` for Svelte markup. |
| **Fractal Limit (INV_7)** | ✅ PASS | Planned modules kept under 400 lines each. No planned contract exceeds 150 lines or CC>10. Decomposition strategy documented in contracts/modules.md. |

**Gate Result**: ✅ ALL PASS — no blocking constitutional or semantic conflicts.

## Project Structure

### Documentation (this feature)

```text
specs/028-llm-datasource-supeset/
├── plan.md              # This file
├── research.md          # Phase 0 output
├── data-model.md        # Phase 1 output
├── quickstart.md        # Phase 1 output
├── contracts/           # Phase 1 output
│   └── modules.md       # Semantic contract design
├── spec.md              # Feature specification
├── ux_reference.md      # Interaction reference
└── checklists/
    └── requirements.md  # Quality validation
```

### Source Code (repository root)

```text
backend/
├── src/
│   ├── api/routes/
│   │   └── translate.py           # New: translation REST endpoints
│   ├── core/
│   │   ├── scheduler.py           # Existing: APScheduler (extend for translation schedules)
│   │   └── superset_client/       # Existing: Superset API client (reuse)
│   ├── models/
│   │   └── translate.py           # New: SQLAlchemy ORM models
│   ├── plugins/
│   │   └── translate/             # New: TranslationPlugin
│   │       ├── __init__.py
│   │       ├── plugin.py          # Plugin entry (inherits PluginBase)
│   │       ├── orchestrator.py    # Run lifecycle orchestration (C5)
│   │       ├── preview.py         # Preview engine (C4)
│   │       ├── executor.py        # Batch execution + INSERT gen (C4)
│   │       ├── dictionary.py      # Dictionary CRUD + filtering (C4)
│   │       ├── sql_generator.py  # INSERT/UPSERT SQL generation (C3)
│   │       ├── scheduler.py       # Schedule management (C4)
│   │       ├── events.py          # Structured event logging (C5)
│   │       ├── metrics.py         # Per-job metrics aggregation (C3)
│   │       └── __tests__/         # Plugin-level tests
│   ├── schemas/
│   │   └── translate.py           # New: Pydantic request/response schemas
│   └── services/
│       ├── llm_provider.py        # Existing: LLM provider management (reuse)
│       └── llm_prompt_templates.py # Existing: prompt rendering (reuse)
└── tests/                         # Integration tests

frontend/
├── src/
│   ├── routes/
│   │   └── translate/             # New: SvelteKit route
│   │       ├── +page.svelte       # Translation job list
│   │       ├── [id]/
│   │       │   └── +page.svelte   # Job config + preview + run
│   │       ├── dictionaries/
│   │       │   ├── +page.svelte   # Dictionary list
│   │       │   └── [id]/
│   │       │       └── +page.svelte # Dictionary editor
│   │       └── history/
│   │           └── +page.svelte   # Run history
│   └── lib/
│       ├── components/
│       │   └── translate/         # New: reusable translation components
│       │       ├── TranslationJobConfig.svelte
│       │       ├── TranslationPreview.svelte
│       │       ├── TranslationRunProgress.svelte
│       │       ├── TranslationRunResult.svelte
│       │       ├── DictionaryEditor.svelte
│       │       ├── TermCorrectionPopup.svelte
│       │       ├── ScheduleConfig.svelte
│       │       └── BulkCorrectionSidebar.svelte
│       ├── stores/
│       │   └── translate.js       # New: Svelte 5 rune stores
│       └── api/
│           └── translate.js       # New: API client module
```

## Semantic Contract Guidance

- All planned contracts follow GRACE-Poly v2.6 protocol with `#region`/`#endregion` anchors (or `[DEF:...]`/`[/DEF:...]` for backward compatibility in docs).
- Python backend uses `# #region`/`# #endregion` comment-anchor syntax.
- Svelte components use `<!-- #region -->`/`<!-- #endregion -->` in markup and `// #region`/`// #endregion` in script blocks.
- Complexity assignments follow strict tag density per GRACE complexity scale (detailed in `contracts/modules.md`).
- C4+ Python modules instrumented with `belief_scope()` + `reason()`/`reflect()`/`explore()` markers.
- C5 contracts carry `@RATIONALE` and `@REJECTED` decision memory (C1-C4 MUST NOT have these tags).
- `@RELATION` targets reference existing contracts where applicable (e.g., `[LLMProviderService:Module]`, `[SchedulerService:Class]`, `[SupersetClient:Module]`, `[NotificationService:Module]`).

## Complexity Tracking

No constitutional violations detected. All complexity assignments are justified within the semantic protocol's complexity scale:

| Contract | Complexity | Justification |
|----------|-----------|---------------|
| `TranslationOrchestrator` | C5 | Stateful lifecycle with PRE/POST, multi-step coordination, decision memory for retry/concurrency policies; updated for multi-target orchestration |
| `TranslationScheduler` | C4 | Stateful schedule CRUD with APScheduler integration, conflict detection |
| `TranslationEventLog` | C5 | Immutable event log with retention enforcement, audit invariants, decision memory for pruning strategy |
| `TranslationPreview` | C4 | Stateful multi-language preview with LLM calls, configurable sample size, approve/edit/reject lifecycle |
| `TranslationExecutor` | C4 | Multi-language batch execution, per-language TranslationLanguage entries, per-language statistics |
| `DictionaryManager` | C4 | Multilingual CRUD with import/export, language-pair-aware batch filtering, conflict resolution |
| `InlineCorrectionService` | C3 | Inline correction with dictionary submission, origin tracking |
| `BulkFindReplaceService` | C3 | Find-and-replace across run results, regex support, multi-language awareness |
| `TranslationLanguage` | C1 | DTO for per-language translation storage |
| `TranslationRunLanguageStats` | C1 | DTO for per-language statistics aggregation |
| `CorrectionCell` (Svelte) | C3 | Inline editable cell with submit-to-dictionary UX state machine |
| `BulkReplaceModal` (Svelte) | C3 | Find-and-replace modal with preview table |
| `ContextAwarePromptBuilder` | C3 | Context-aware dictionary prompt construction with Jaccard similarity, priority flagging, context truncation |
| `InlineCorrectionService` (extended) | C3 | Context capture from source rows, context editing, usage notes, context_source tagging |
| Other Svelte components | C3 | Existing components updated with per-language columns, configurable preview, context display |